How to Remove Vocals from a Song in Audacity (+ Why AI Works Better)

Audacity is everyone's go-to free audio editor, and naturally, people wonder if it can remove vocals from songs. Short answer: yes, but results are often disappointing. Here's exactly how to do it — and why AI tools produce dramatically better results.

TL;DR: In Audacity, go to Effect → Vocal Reduction and Isolation → Select "Remove Vocals" → Apply. Results vary wildly because Audacity uses phase cancellation, which only works on certain mixes. For consistent quality, AI vocal removal works on any song.

How to Remove Vocals in Audacity (Quick Steps)

1. Open Audacity
2. File → Import → Audio (select your song)
3. Select All (Ctrl+A / Cmd+A)
4. Effect → Vocal Reduction and Isolation
5. Choose "Remove Vocals" from dropdown
6. Click Apply
7. File → Export Audio

That's the quick version. Keep reading for detailed steps, settings explanations, and why results may disappoint you.

Step-by-Step Tutorial with Screenshots

Step 1: Download and Install Audacity

If you haven't already:

1. Go to audacityteam.org
2. Download for your platform (Windows, Mac, Linux)
3. Install with default settings

Audacity is completely free and open source.

Step 2: Import Your Audio File

1. Open Audacity
2. Go to File → Import → Audio
3. Select your song file (MP3, WAV, FLAC, etc.)
4. Wait for the waveform to load

You'll see the stereo waveform displayed in the main window.

Step 3: Select the Entire Track

Click anywhere in the waveform, then:

• Keyboard shortcut: Ctrl+A (Windows) or Cmd+A (Mac)
• Or: Edit → Select → All

The entire waveform should be highlighted.

Step 4: Apply Vocal Reduction and Isolation

1. Go to Effect → Vocal Reduction and Isolation

2. In the dialog that appears, you'll see a dropdown with options:

   • Remove Vocals — What we want
   • Isolate Vocals — Keeps only vocals
   • Remove Center — Removes center-panned content
   • Isolate Center — Keeps only center content

3. Select "Remove Vocals"

Step 5: Adjust Settings (Optional)

The default settings work for most attempts, but you can adjust:

Tip: If you hear too much bass loss, lower the "Low Cut" value. If the result is too thin, try "Isolate Center and Invert" instead of "Remove Vocals."

Step 6: Preview and Apply

1. Click Preview to hear a sample
2. Adjust settings if needed
3. Click Apply when satisfied

Processing takes a few seconds depending on song length.

Step 7: Export Your Result

1. Go to File → Export Audio
2. Choose format (MP3 or WAV recommended)
3. Name your file
4. Click Save

Why Audacity Vocal Removal Often Fails

Here's the frustrating truth: Audacity's vocal removal only works well on specific types of recordings.

How It Actually Works

Audacity uses phase cancellation and center channel extraction:

1. Assumes vocals are panned exactly center (0 position)
2. Assumes instruments are panned left/right
3. Inverts and combines stereo channels
4. Identical (centered) content cancels out
5. Different (panned) content remains

Why This Fails on Most Songs

Problem 1: Vocals aren't always perfectly centered

• Modern productions often have stereo-widened vocals
• Backup vocals may be panned
• Vocal doubles spread across stereo field

Problem 2: Other instruments are centered too

• Bass guitar is almost always centered
• Kick drum is centered
• Snare drum often centered
• These get removed along with vocals

Problem 3: Reverb and effects survive

• Vocal reverb is usually stereo
• Reverb tails remain even when dry vocal is removed
• Creates ghostly, obviously-processed sound

Expected Results by Song Type

The Better Alternative: AI Vocal Removal

AI-powered vocal removal works fundamentally differently — and dramatically better.

How AI Works

Instead of phase tricks, AI uses neural networks trained on thousands of professionally separated songs:

1. Learns what vocals sound like — Timbre, frequency patterns, characteristics
2. Identifies vocals regardless of panning — Works on any stereo position
3. Separates by sound type, not position — Bass stays, vocals go
4. Handles effects and reverb — Removes vocal content including reverb tails

Quality Comparison

Side-by-Side Example

Same song processed both ways:

Audacity result:

• Vocals partially removed
• Bass noticeably quieter
• Thin, hollow sound
• Vocal reverb clearly audible

AI result:

• Vocals cleanly removed
• Full bass presence
• Natural, full sound
• Minimal artifacts

---

Tried Audacity and disappointed? StemSplit uses AI to remove vocals from any song with consistent quality. Preview 30 seconds free before downloading.

Try AI Vocal Removal →

---

Advanced Audacity Techniques

If you want to try getting better results in Audacity, here are some advanced approaches:

Method 2: Isolate Vocals and Invert

Sometimes this works better than "Remove Vocals":

1. Duplicate your track (Ctrl+D / Cmd+D)
2. On the duplicate: Effect → Vocal Reduction and Isolation → Isolate Vocals
3. Select the isolated vocals track
4. Effect → Invert
5. Select both tracks
6. Tracks → Mix → Mix and Render

This creates a more controlled subtraction.

Method 3: Nyquist Plugins

Audacity supports third-party Nyquist plugins that may work better:

1. Search for "Audacity vocal isolation plugins"
2. Download .ny files
3. Place in Audacity plugins folder
4. Enable in Effect menu
5. Try different plugins for different results

Method 4: Manual EQ Approach

Very limited, but can reduce vocals slightly:

1. Effect → Filter Curve EQ
2. Cut frequencies around 1-4 kHz (vocal range)
3. This removes other instruments too, but may help in specific cases

Honest assessment: None of these methods approach AI quality. They're worth trying if you absolutely need free options, but manage expectations.

When to Use Audacity vs AI

Use Audacity When:

• Budget is zero (truly free)
• Song has simple, centered vocals
• "Good enough" is acceptable
• You're experimenting/learning
• Processing many files quickly (batch)

Use AI (StemSplit) When:

• Quality matters
• Song is modern/complex
• You need consistent results
• Creating karaoke for performance
• Professional use

FAQ

Why does Audacity work on some songs but not others?

Audacity's method depends on vocals being perfectly centered and instruments being panned wide. Songs mixed this way (some older recordings, simple pop) work better. Modern productions with stereo-wide vocals fail.

Is there a plugin that makes Audacity work better?

Various Nyquist plugins exist, but none match AI quality. The fundamental limitation is the phase cancellation approach, not the specific implementation.

Can Audacity isolate vocals (not remove them)?

Yes — use "Isolate Vocals" instead of "Remove Vocals" in the Vocal Reduction and Isolation effect. Same limitations apply: works on some songs, fails on others.

Why does the bass disappear when I remove vocals?

Bass instruments are almost always mixed to the center of the stereo field. Audacity's center-removal technique removes everything centered, including bass.

How long does Audacity processing take?

A few seconds for most songs. Much faster than AI processing, but quality difference is significant.

Is AI vocal removal free?

Some free options exist with limitations (VocalRemover.org). For consistent quality, paid tools like StemSplit offer pay-per-song pricing — no subscription, just pay for what you use.

The Bottom Line

Audacity's vocal removal is free and sometimes works, but it's fundamentally limited by its phase cancellation approach. For songs where it works, great — it costs nothing. For the majority of modern music, you'll be disappointed.

If vocal removal quality matters for your project, AI tools like StemSplit produce consistently better results on any song. The technology has advanced dramatically, and what AI achieves in 60 seconds surpasses what any traditional method can do.

Try Audacity first — it's free. Use AI when Audacity fails — and it will on most songs.

---

When Audacity Isn't Enough

AI vocal removal works on any song, not just simple mixes.

• ✅ Works on modern productions
• ✅ Preserves bass and instruments
• ✅ Consistent quality every time
• ✅ Preview free before paying

Try AI Vocal Removal →

---